Bilkins' Folly

Unlock all other trophies

Cause a seagull to crash into the camera

Find your first piece of junk

Reach Crabb Island

Collect 5 pieces of booty

8 pieces of junk

Reach Phelmy Island

Unlock the ship

Snag a fish

Mine a gold nugget

Reach Remy's Lott

32 pieces of junk

Collect 20 pieces of booty

Decide Philmore's fate

Reach Leeky Harbor

burgle every home in Leeky Harbor

Fully upgrade your ship

Beat the minecart puzzle

Reach Shattered Peak

Have a conversation with Rosemary

Beat the bats dungeon

Collect La Moina's key

Share an informative meal with the crew

Make amends with the boss of Remy's Lott

Solve all of Carlos' songs

beat the game without ever turning on normal mode

pat all the animals

find 64 pieces of junk

find every gold nugget

collect every piece of gear

Collect every last piece of booty

Fame or family - make a choice

catch every fish

find all the quest items, gold nuggets, pearls, booty, diary pages, junk and fish... phew!

Find a secret in Drayton's dream world

Come to a resolution with Gail

Have a conversation with Winston